Gifts For Supernatural Fans [TOP PICKS]

Note: This page contains affiliate links. 
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases when you click on the link, but you are not charged extra.

Shopping for a gift can be a thrilling experience, but it can also feel like a monumental challenge, especially when it comes to finding something truly special for someone who has a passionate interest in a specific fandom. Supernatural fans, in particular, can be a tough crowd to shop for. Their love for the genre spans across TV shows, books, movies, and even real-world mythology, making the gift-giving process both exciting and potentially overwhelming.

When it comes to Supernatural, a long-running show about hunting demons, ghosts, angels, and other mythical creatures, the fandom has evolved into a rich subculture of its own. So, finding a gift that truly resonates with a Supernatural fan isn’t just about picking up any random merchandise-it’s about tapping into the unique elements of the show and its rich lore that fans know and love.

This guide will walk you through everything you need to know about buying gifts for Supernatural fans, from how to figure out what they truly want to avoiding common pitfalls, to finding the best places to shop. By the time you’re done reading, you’ll be well-equipped to choose the perfect gift that any Supernatural fan will appreciate.

10 Gifts For Supernatural Fans

1. TV Show Merchandise

If you have a friend or family member who lives and breathes the Supernatural TV series, this category is an absolute goldmine. From t-shirts and hoodies to posters and action figures, there’s a little something for every kind of fan. Imagine their face lighting up when they unwrap a collectible that features their favorite Winchesters or even a replica of their iconic weapons-pure joy guaranteed!

Beyond clothing and decor, TV show merchandise also gives fans a chance to express their love for the series in everyday life. They can proudly wear their fandom to conventions, movie nights, or just around the house. It’s not just a gift; it’s a way for them to feel connected to the world of Supernatural every single day.

Top Picks:

2. Funko Pop! Figures

Ah, Funko Pop! figures-tiny, adorable, and utterly collectible. If your gift recipient enjoys decorating their desk, bookshelf, or gaming setup, a Supernatural-themed Pop! figure is a perfect addition. These figures capture the quirks and personalities of their favorite characters in a fun, stylized way, making them a visual treat for fans of all ages.

Plus, Funko Pops! are great conversation starters. Guests might glance at the shelf and instantly recognize the characters, sparking delightful discussions about favorite episodes or iconic moments. For the Supernatural fan who loves to show off their collection proudly, these little figures are pure gold.

Top Picks:

3. Books and Graphic Novels

Supernatural fans often love diving deeper into lore and character backstories, and books or graphic novels are an amazing way to do that. From official companion books that explore the making of the series to supernatural-themed novels inspired by the show, this category can offer hours of immersive reading.

It’s the kind of gift that keeps on giving because each page can transport them back to the world of monsters, angels, and epic battles. Whether they’re curling up on the couch or reading in bed, it’s the perfect way to combine their love of storytelling with their favorite TV universe.

Top Picks:

4. Jewelry and Accessories

For the subtle fan who loves to show their passion without shouting it, jewelry and accessories are a fantastic choice. Think angel wing necklaces, anti-possession rings, or charms inspired by the show. They make everyday outfits feel a little more magical and let fans carry a piece of Supernatural with them wherever they go.

These gifts are not only stylish but also meaningful. Each piece can remind the fan of their favorite episodes, characters, or iconic moments. It’s a personal and thoughtful way to connect their everyday life with the supernatural world they adore.

Top Picks:

5. Home Decor

If the person you’re buying for loves turning their space into a shrine of fandom, home decor items are a win. Think posters, throw blankets, or even wall clocks featuring Supernatural motifs. These items can instantly give a room a cozy, themed vibe that any fan would love to show off.

It’s the kind of gift that keeps their love for the series visible and vibrant. Every time they walk into the room, they’ll be reminded of epic battles, hilarious moments, or the emotional storylines that made them a fan in the first place. Home decor gifts are practical, stylish, and utterly fan-approved.

Top Picks:

6. Board Games and Puzzles

Fans who enjoy a little hands-on fun will go wild for Supernatural-themed board games and puzzles. Whether it’s a trivia game testing their knowledge of every episode or a puzzle that forms a chilling scene from the show, this category offers interactive entertainment that’s perfect for friends and family game nights.

It’s also a gift that encourages creativity and bonding. As they solve puzzles or strategize in a game, they get to relive iconic moments and share laughs with fellow fans. The best part? These gifts are engaging and memorable, making them far more than just another collectible.

Top Picks:

7. Clothing and Apparel

Beyond hoodies and t-shirts, clothing and apparel in this category can include pajama sets, socks, and even themed hats. Fans get to wear their love for the show proudly, whether lounging at home or heading out to meet fellow enthusiasts at conventions.

It’s a gift that’s both practical and fun. Imagine gifting a cozy Supernatural pajama set for binge-watching nights-that’s comfort and fandom rolled into one. Fans will appreciate the thoughtfulness behind gifts they can actually wear and enjoy daily.

Top Picks:

8. Mugs and Drinkware

Every fan needs a way to fuel up for long episodes or marathon viewing sessions, and mugs or drinkware featuring Supernatural themes are perfect. From coffee mugs with witty quotes to travel tumblers adorned with iconic characters, these gifts are both practical and fandom-friendly.

A mug is more than just a vessel for coffee or tea; it’s a daily reminder of their favorite show. Every sip becomes a moment of connection with the world of hunters, monsters, and angels. It’s a simple yet thoughtful way to celebrate their passion.

Top Picks:

9. Collectible Props and Replicas

For fans who love immersing themselves in the show’s universe, collectible props and replicas are a dream come true. Think replicas of the Colt, angel blades, or even Sam and Dean’s iconic leather jacket. These are the kinds of gifts that make their collection feel museum-worthy.

These items are especially perfect for fans who enjoy cosplay or displaying memorabilia. They offer a tangible connection to the series, letting fans bring a piece of Supernatural into the real world. It’s a wow-factor gift that will have them grinning from ear to ear.

Top Picks:

10. Stationery and Office Supplies

Even mundane office tasks get a supernatural twist with themed stationery and office supplies. Fans can enjoy notebooks, pens, planners, and even sticky notes adorned with quotes or images from the show. It’s a subtle way to sprinkle fandom into everyday life.

This category is perfect for students, writers, or anyone who spends time at a desk. Every time they jot down a note or organize their schedule, they’ll get a little thrill from seeing their favorite characters nearby. It’s a mix of practicality and fan devotion that’s surprisingly delightful.

Top Picks:

Buyer Guide For Gifts For Supernatural Fans

When you’re shopping for someone who’s a die-hard Supernatural fan, there are a few key things to keep in mind to ensure that your gift stands out. Fans of the show don’t just love the characters-they adore the world-building, the mythology, and the deeper themes that run throughout each season. The following are some pointers to guide you through the process of picking out the perfect Supernatural-themed gift.

Understand the Fandom’s Themes: Supernatural isn’t just about hunting monsters; it’s about family, loyalty, sacrifice, and fighting against the odds. Gifts that reflect these themes, like personalized family-themed items or symbols representing the Winchester brothers’ bond (such as the famous “protective” sigil), are likely to resonate deeply with a fan.
Get Specific with the Show: Supernatural has 15 seasons, and within those seasons, there are story arcs, characters, and iconic moments that fans gravitate toward. For example:
- Dean Winchester’s Car (The Impala): This car isn’t just a vehicle; it’s almost a character in itself. Gifts that feature the Impala-whether it’s a detailed model car, a plush version, or even art prints of it-are always a hit.
- Hunter Gear: Think of iconic items like the Colt, Devil’s Trap, or angel blades. Gifts that mimic these items in real life, like collectible replicas or even wearable versions, can excite fans of the show.
- Quotes and Catchphrases: Supernatural is full of memorable lines, like “Driver picks the music, shotgun shuts his cakehole.” Gifts that feature iconic quotes on posters, t-shirts, or mugs can add a personal touch.
Fan Art and Custom Pieces: Fans of Supernatural often appreciate unique artwork or custom-made items that feel personal and special. Consider commissioning a piece of fan art that reflects the show’s atmosphere or a favorite character, or find custom-made jewelry or apparel inspired by the show.
Practicality vs. Sentimental Value: You can go either route depending on the person’s personality:
- Practical Gifts: Mugs, blankets, clothing, or even a Supernatural-themed phone case or laptop sleeve are often appreciated by those who enjoy day-to-day use of their fandom-related items.
- Sentimental Gifts: If you’re aiming for something more meaningful, look for rare collectibles, signed memorabilia, or limited-edition pieces that tie into significant moments or story arcs.
Consider the Fandom’s Subcategories: Supernatural fans often specialize in certain characters, creatures, or specific storylines. Some might be all about Castiel (the angel), while others may prefer Crowley (the demon) or the infamous “Yellow-Eyed Demon”. Understand their preferences to tailor your gift accordingly.

How To Learn What Someone Really Wants

Picking the perfect gift doesn’t have to be a guessing game. In fact, it’s easier than it seems once you know the right questions to ask-and the signs to look for in their day-to-day life. Here are some strategies you can use to uncover exactly what a Supernatural fan might want:

Pay Attention to Their Existing Collection: Do they already have Supernatural memorabilia? What do they like to talk about most when discussing the show? Whether they have a collection of Funko Pop figures, Supernatural-themed jewelry, or even books related to the show, seeing what they already have can give you a clue about their fandom interests.
Ask Subtle Questions: If you’re unsure what they’d want, ask leading questions that let you gauge what they enjoy most. For example:
- “I was thinking about getting you a Supernatural gift. Do you have a favorite character or season?”
- “Which moment in Supernatural really stuck with you”?
- “Are there any collectibles or items from the show you”ve been eyeing”?
Look to Social Media: If they’re active on platforms like Instagram, Twitter, or Tumblr, you can find valuable clues. Fans often share pictures of new merch they’ve acquired, discuss their favorite episodes, or even express what they’re missing in their collections.
Engage with Online Communities: Join Supernatural fan forums or Reddit threads and engage with others about the fandom. You might get some great ideas for gifts that you wouldn’t have thought of on your own.
Personalized Gifts Are Always a Win: If you know someone’s favorite quote, character, or specific memory from the show, you can create a gift tailored just for them. Custom gifts can range from engraved necklaces to a personalized scrapbook, so don’t hesitate to go the extra mile.

Top Gift-Giving Errors To Watch Out For

Gift-giving might seem straightforward, but there are some common pitfalls you should avoid to make sure your present doesn’t miss the mark. Here are the top mistakes people often make when shopping for a Supernatural fan:

Generalizing the Fandom: Not every fan is the same, and assuming they’ll love anything with the Supernatural logo on it can backfire. Take the time to personalize the gift based on their specific likes within the show.
Choosing Low-Quality Products: Fans who are invested in the Supernatural universe are often quite discerning when it comes to the quality of merchandise. Avoid cheap, poorly made products-especially if they’re meant to be a centerpiece of their collection. Look for high-quality materials, attention to detail, and licensed merchandise when possible.
Overdoing the ’Cliché’ Gifts: While a t-shirt with a basic Supernatural logo might seem like a safe bet, it’s also one of the most generic and overdone gifts. Fans of the show likely have a whole drawer of t-shirts like that. Try to think outside the box for something more creative or personal.
Ignoring the Budget: It’s easy to get carried away when buying for a passionate fan, but make sure your gift is within your budget. You can find unique, thoughtful gifts at various price points, so it’s better to pick something meaningful within your range than something extravagant but impersonal.
Forgetting About Their Interests Outside the Show: While Supernatural is a huge part of their life, your gift should also reflect their other interests. A fan might appreciate something that ties into their love of supernatural creatures in general-like a book on folklore or a piece of artwork inspired by classic horror movies-rather than strictly Supernatural-themed items.

Best Places To Shop For Gifts

Now that you’ve got a handle on what to look for and avoid, it’s time to find the best places to shop for Supernatural gifts. There are a ton of online and physical stores that cater to the fandom, so where do you begin?

Etsy: This is a fantastic place for finding unique, handmade, and custom Supernatural-themed gifts. From custom jewelry to personalized prints and one-of-a-kind artwork, Etsy offers a wealth of options for Supernatural fans that you won’t find anywhere else.
Amazon: While Amazon is a go-to for convenience, it also has a surprisingly wide range of licensed Supernatural merchandise. Look for high-quality items like books, collectible figurines, and replica gear.
Hot Topic: Known for its fandom-related products, Hot Topic is a solid choice for Supernatural apparel, collectibles, and other themed merchandise. You’ll find a mix of both classic and new items.
Supernatural Fan Conventions: If you happen to be near a Supernatural convention, attending one is an excellent opportunity to find exclusive merch that can’t be found online or in stores. Plus, you may even get the chance to meet actors from the show!
Official Supernatural Merchandise Store: The show has its own official store where you can find a range of high-quality merchandise, including limited-edition items, posters, clothing, and other collectibles.
Redbubble: If you’re looking for custom art or fan designs, Redbubble is the place to go. Artists from all over the world upload unique Supernatural-inspired artwork on everything from shirts to phone cases, making it a great place to find something a little more personal.